Quest2ReasonClimb the mountain, sharpen your mind.

Ideas

Fallacies

35 common mistakes in reasoning. Each has its own page: what it is, an everyday example, how to spot it and how to answer it fairly.

All fallacies

Ad hominemAttacking the person making an argument instead of the argument itself.Changing the subjectLesson on the climbTu quoqueDismissing a criticism because the critic does the same thing.Changing the subjectLesson on the climbGenetic fallacyJudging a claim by where it came from or why someone holds it, rather than by the evidence.Changing the subjectLesson on the climbStraw manReplacing someone’s argument with a weaker or more extreme version, then knocking that down.Changing the subjectLesson on the climbRed herringBringing in a different issue to pull attention away from the one being discussed.Changing the subjectLesson on the climbAppeal to emotionUsing feelings such as fear, pity or pride in place of reasons.Changing the subjectLesson on the climbAppeal to consequencesDeciding whether something is true by whether you would like the result.Changing the subjectLesson on the climbBandwagonTreating a claim as true because many people believe it.Leaning on the wrong supportLesson on the climbAppeal to authorityAccepting a claim because someone famous or important said it, outside their expertise or without reasons.Leaning on the wrong supportLesson on the climbAppeal to natureAssuming that what is natural is good or safe, and what is artificial is bad.Leaning on the wrong supportLesson on the climbAppeal to traditionTreating a practice as right because it is old or customary.Leaning on the wrong supportLesson on the climbAppeal to ignoranceClaiming something is true because it has not been proved false, or false because it has not been proved true.Leaning on the wrong supportLesson on the climbSunk cost fallacyContinuing something because of what you have already spent on it, rather than what lies ahead.Leaning on the wrong supportLesson on the climbFalse dilemmaPresenting two options as the only ones when there are more.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbSlippery slopeClaiming one small step will inevitably lead to a chain of extreme results, without showing why.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbBegging the questionUsing the conclusion, in other words, as one of the reasons for it.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbLoaded questionAsking a question that smuggles in an assumption, so any direct answer accepts it.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbMoving the goalpostsChanging what counts as evidence after the original test has been met.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbNo true ScotsmanProtecting a generalization by redefining the group to exclude any counterexample.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbMotte and baileyAdvancing a bold claim, retreating to a modest one when challenged, then advancing again.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbSpecial pleadingApplying a rule to others while claiming an exception for yourself without a good reason.Rigging the questionLesson on the climbEquivocationShifting between two meanings of the same word partway through an argument.Slippery words and shapesLesson on the climbComposition and divisionAssuming what is true of the parts is true of the whole, or what is true of the whole is true of each part.Slippery words and shapesLesson on the climbAffirming the consequentReasoning from “if A then B” and “B” to “A”, which does not follow.Slippery words and shapesLesson on the climbDenying the antecedentReasoning from “if A then B” and “not A” to “not B”, which does not follow.Slippery words and shapesLesson on the climbWeak analogyArguing that two things are alike in one way because they are alike in others, when the differences matter.Slippery words and shapesLesson on the climbPost hocAssuming that because one thing happened after another, the first caused the second.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbCorrelation is not causationConcluding that because two things go together, one causes the other.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbHasty generalizationDrawing a general conclusion from too few or untypical cases.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbCherry-pickingShowing only the evidence that supports a claim and leaving out the rest.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbTexas sharpshooterFinding a pattern in random data after the fact, then treating it as meaningful.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbSurvivorship biasDrawing conclusions from the cases that made it through a filter, and forgetting the ones that did not.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbGambler’s fallacyBelieving that a random event is more or less likely because of what happened just before.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbBase rate fallacyIgnoring how common something is in general when judging a particular case.Bad evidenceLesson on the climbConjunction fallacyJudging a detailed story as more likely than a simpler one it contains.Bad evidenceLesson on the climb

The five kinds

Changing the subject
Answering something other than the argument: the person, a distorted version, or a feeling.
Leaning on the wrong support
Treating popularity, fame, nature, habit or silence as if it were evidence.
Rigging the question
Building the answer into the setup, or changing the rules once the test is under way.
Slippery words and shapes
Arguments that look valid because of a shifting word or a borrowed shape.
Bad evidence
Mistakes about causes, samples and chances: the story outruns the numbers.